The Muttontown Club
Course at a glance
The Muttontown Club is an 18-hole golf course in Village of Muttontown, New York (11732). The course was designed by Alfred H. Tull and opened in 1959. From the Black tees, The Muttontown Club plays to 6,561 yards at par 71. The course offers 6 sets of tees ranging from 5,550 to 6,561 yards, giving players of every ability a comfortable length. It carries a slope rating of 133 and a course rating of 71.6, comfortably above the 113 World Handicap System baseline and demanding accurate driving. That ranks it harder than roughly 69% of rated golf courses in New York. It is a public course open to daily-fee play. Walking is permitted. A pro shop is on site. The course is conditioned with bent grass greens and bent grass fairways. Hazards include 21-30 bunkers and water hazards in play. Tee times at The Muttontown Club are booked through the course's official website or pro shop; Stymie does not show live tee-time inventory.
About The Muttontown Club
The Muttontown Club is a 18-hole golf course located in Village of Muttontown, New York (11732). The course was designed by Alfred H. Tull and established in 1959. From the Black tees, the course plays to 6,561 yards with a par of 71. The Black tees carry a slope rating of 133 and a course rating of 71.6.
Walking is permitted.
The Muttontown Club offers a moderately challenging layout with a slope rating of 136, putting it in the upper half of courses in New York for difficulty. The course provides a fair test for golfers of most skill levels.
The course offers 6 tee sets ranging from 5,550 to 6,561 yards, making it accessible to golfers of all skill levels. Choosing the right tees for your handicap is the single biggest factor in how much you enjoy your round.
Golf in New York typically runs from May through October. Spring and fall offer the best conditions with lower humidity and fewer crowds. Book early for prime weekend morning tee times during peak summer months.
Par
71
Length
6,561
Slope
133
Rating
71.6
Course Difficulty Analysis
136
This Course
130
NY Average
113
US Average
Based on 511 rated courses in New York
Scorecard
| Hole | Slp | CR | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | Out | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | In | Tot |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Black | 133 | 71.6 | 341 | 378 | 443 | 201 | 332 | 421 | 149 | 531 | 345 | 3141 | 415 | 407 | 566 | 465 | 155 | 311 | 166 | 529 | 406 | 3420 | 6,561 |
BlueWomen's | 136 | 75.5 | 323 | 362 | 426 | 186 | 316 | 405 | 131 | 505 | 322 | 2976 | 374 | 384 | 513 | 400 | 137 | 297 | 145 | 513 | 392 | 3155 | 6,131 |
BlueMen's | 129 | 69.5 | 323 | 362 | 426 | 186 | 316 | 405 | 131 | 505 | 322 | 2976 | 374 | 384 | 513 | 400 | 137 | 297 | 145 | 513 | 392 | 3155 | 6,131 |
WhiteWomen's | 132 | 73.8 | 311 | 347 | 406 | 173 | 306 | 392 | 120 | 498 | 307 | 2860 | 359 | 377 | 496 | 334 | 124 | 291 | 132 | 489 | 373 | 2975 | 5,835 |
WhiteMen's | 127 | 68.1 | 311 | 347 | 406 | 173 | 306 | 392 | 120 | 498 | 307 | 2860 | 359 | 377 | 496 | 334 | 124 | 291 | 132 | 489 | 373 | 2975 | 5,835 |
Red | 130 | 71.9 | 305 | 295 | 415 | 164 | 299 | 327 | 115 | 467 | 283 | 2670 | 346 | 371 | 466 | 330 | 118 | 286 | 122 | 473 | 368 | 2880 | 5,550 |
| Par | 4 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 5 | 4 | 35 | 4 | 4 | 5 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 5 | 4 | 36 | 71 | ||
| HCP | 15 | 9 | 1 | 7 | 17 | 3 | 13 | 5 | 11 | 12 | 4 | 8 | 2 | 16 | 18 | 14 | 10 | 6 |
Which Tees Should I Play?
The Muttontown Club offers 6 tee sets. Choose the tees that match your handicap for the most enjoyable round. Not sure? Use the tee recommendation calculator with your driver distance.
| Tee | Yards | Slope | Rating | Hcp |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Black | 6,561 | 133 | 71.6 | 5-15 |
Blue | 6,131 | 136 | 75.5 | 12-22 |
Blue | 6,131 | 129 | 69.5 | 12-22 |
White | 5,835 | 132 | 73.8 | 12-22 |
White | 5,835 | 127 | 68.1 | 12-22 |
Red | 5,550 | 130 | 71.9 | 20-30 |
Amenities at The Muttontown Club
The Muttontown Club features a pro shop.
Find driving ranges near The Muttontown Club →
How to Book a Tee Time
Stymie does not currently show live tee-time inventory for The Muttontown Club. Use the official course website or phone number below to confirm availability and book.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is The Muttontown Club a public or private golf course?
The Muttontown Club is a public golf course located in Village of Muttontown, NY. The course is open to the public for daily fee play.
How many holes does The Muttontown Club have?
The Muttontown Club is a 18-hole golf course. It was established in 1959. The course was designed by Alfred H. Tull.
What is the yardage at The Muttontown Club?
From the White tees, The Muttontown Club plays to 5,835 yards (par 72). The course offers 6 tee sets ranging from 5,550 to 6,561 yards.
What is the slope rating at The Muttontown Club?
The Black tees at The Muttontown Club have a slope rating of 133 and a course rating of 71.6. A slope of 113 is average difficulty; this course is significantly above average difficulty.
Can you walk The Muttontown Club?
Yes, walking is allowed at The Muttontown Club. Golf carts are also available.
How do I book a tee time at The Muttontown Club?
Contact the course directly or call 516-922-7500 to confirm current availability and book. Stymie does not currently show live tee-time inventory; alerts are in development.
What amenities does The Muttontown Club offer?
The Muttontown Club offers a pro shop.
Where is The Muttontown Club located?
The Muttontown Club is located at Route 25 A in Village of Muttontown, NY 11732. You can reach them at 516-922-7500.
What is the difficulty level at The Muttontown Club?
The Muttontown Club is classified as very high difficulty with a maximum slope rating of 136. It plays harder than 69% of golf courses in New York. The average slope rating in New York is 130. A slope rating of 113 represents average difficulty nationally.
Which tees should I play at The Muttontown Club?
The Muttontown Club offers 6 tee sets. Black tees (6,561 yards, slope 133) are recommended for mid-low handicap golfers. Red tees (5,550 yards, slope 130) are recommended for higher-handicap golfers and seniors. Choose the tee set where the slope rating is closest to your handicap comfort level.
What is the best tee for beginners at The Muttontown Club?
Beginners at The Muttontown Club should play the Red tees, which play 5,550 yards with a slope of 130. This is the most forgiving tee option and provides an enjoyable round for newer golfers.
What is the course handicap for a 15 Handicap Index at The Muttontown Club?
A golfer with a 15.0 Handicap Index playing the White tees (slope 132, rating 73.8) at The Muttontown Club has a course handicap of 19, using the World Handicap System formula: Course Handicap = Handicap Index × (Slope / 113) + (Course Rating − Par). Course handicap is the number of handicap strokes received from that tee — it is not a prediction of what a golfer will score. Enter your handicap index on Stymie to see your course handicap for every tee.
How long does a round take at The Muttontown Club?
A typical round at The Muttontown Club takes approximately 4 hours. Expect 3.5 to 4.5 hours depending on pace of play, group size, and course conditions. Weekday rounds tend to be faster than weekend morning tee times.